Star Voting

TL;DR:
In STAR Voting, voters rate each option (e.g. 0–5 stars). After all ballots are scored, the two highest-rated options go to a runoff—and the option preferred by a majority wins. This lets people express support for multiple ideas without vote-splitting.
STAR Voting (Score Then Automatic Runoff) solves several problems found in first-past-the-post and ranked-choice voting systems:
- It allows voters to support multiple strong candidates
- It reduces strategic voting
- It ensures the winner is both well-liked and broadly supported
Though originally developed for political elections, STAR Voting has potential in Web3 for:
- DAO decision-making
- Project prioritization
- Grants selection
- Round governance
In onchain or offchain systems, STAR Voting can be used to score proposals, contributors, or domains before a final decision. It encourages expressiveness (via scoring) while still producing a single, decisive outcome.
Best For
- Selecting one option from many
- Communities seeking fairer, more expressive voting
- Governance decisions where consensus and decisiveness both matter
- Rounds or allocations where multiple good options exist
Good At
- Avoiding vote-splitting and polarization
- Encouraging honest expression of preferences
- Producing clear winners without runoffs dragging on
- Supporting voter nuance and decisiveness in one round
Dependencies / Requirements
- A UI to support scoring ballots (0–5 scale)
- Infrastructure to calculate aggregate scores
- Logic to identify top two and determine majority preference
- Optional sybil resistance or weighting mechanisms
Not Good At
- Funding many options simultaneously
- Continuous or real-time voting scenarios
- Environments needing proportional representation
- Low-participation groups (may produce distorted scoring)
Who Should Use It?
- DAOs looking for expressive yet decisive governance tools
- Communities selecting a lead project, steward, or proposal
- Ecosystems where multiple good options compete and voters need nuance
- Protocols experimenting with post-binary voting systems
Example Use Cases
- A DAO uses STAR Voting to choose one proposal to fund from a list of six
- A grants committee uses STAR to let voters rate all projects, with a final runoff between the two top scorers
- A community selects a new core steward via STAR Voting, ensuring the winner has both high ratings and broad support